Key Points
- Mayor of London Sadiq Khan (Lord Khan) has broken ranks with Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley to oppose proposals that would merge the City of London Police into the Metropolitan Police Service.
- Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood commissioned former Metropolitan Police Commissioner Lord Bernard Hogan-Howe in March 2026 to draw up a blueprint reducing the 43 police forces across England and Wales into fewer, larger regional “mega-forces”.
- Although Lord Hogan-Howe’s review has not yet been officially published, the Financial Times reported that it recommends creating nine regional mega-forces and folding the City of London Police—which also leads national fraud and economic crime investigations—into the Met.
- Sadiq Khan praised the City of London Police for doing “an excellent job” with strong financial backing from the City of London Corporation, stating: “If it ain’t broken, why fix it?”
- Thirteen regional mayors across England previously signed a May 2026 letter demanding that police force boundaries align with devolved mayoral regions, prompting ministers to reportedly consider scaling back the plans.
- Police Foundation think tank representative Blair Gibbs questioned whether absorbing the Square Mile’s force into the Metropolitan Police would improve policing services for residents and workers in the financial district.
London (Britain Today News) November 16, 2026 – Mayor of London Sadiq Khan has publicly opposed Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley over proposals to absorb the City of London Police into the Metropolitan Police Service as part of a nationwide restructuring of policing in England and Wales. As reported by Political Correspondent Aaron Newbury, Lord Khan joined a growing coalition of regional mayors resisting government-commissioned plans to consolidate 43 local police forces into larger regional “mega-forces”. Whilst Sir Mark Rowley has argued that merging forces is essential to end fragmented leadership in tackling fraud and cybercrime, Sadiq Khan insisted that the City of London force is performing strongly and requires no structural overhaul.
- Key Points
- Why Is Sadiq Khan Opposing the Merger of the City of London Police and the Met?
- What Are the Government’s “Mega-Force” Policing Reform Proposals?
- How Have Other Regional Mayors and Ministers Responded to the Restructuring Plans?
- Background of the City of London Police and UK Police Force Restructuring
- How Could This Dispute Affect Londoners, the Financial Sector, and UK Policing Policy?
Why Is Sadiq Khan Opposing the Merger of the City of London Police and the Met?
Mayor of London Sadiq Khan stated that the City of London Police is performing at a high standard with substantial financial backing from the City of London Corporation, arguing that absorbing the force into the Metropolitan Police would undermine clear local accountability.
Speaking out against proposals to fold the historic Square Mile force into the wider capital’s police service, Sadiq Khan praised the operational record of the City of London Police. As reported by Aaron Newbury, Lord Khan stated last month that the City force was doing “an excellent job” and noted that the City of London Corporation backed them “to the hilt”, investing in them “in ways that we simply can’t for a variety of reasons”.
Addressing the proposed restructuring directly, Sadiq Khan added: “I’m also a believer in the view, ‘If it ain’t broken, why fix it?’”
Acknowledging a direct policy disagreement with Britain’s most senior police officer, Lord Khan confirmed that Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley did not share his position. “I have been making those views known privately and I’ll continue to do so publicly as well,” Lord Khan stated, as reported by Aaron Newbury. A spokesperson for the Mayor of London further emphasised that maintaining “strong and clear local accountability” remains vital for policing across London.
Independent policing analysts have echoed doubts regarding the operational benefits of a merger. Blair Gibbs, of the Police Foundation think tank, stated: “I’m not persuaded that there’s anything about the Metropolitan Police that would enhance the service of the City of London Police to those who live and work in the Square Mile.”
What Are the Government’s “Mega-Force” Policing Reform Proposals?
In March 2026, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood commissioned former Metropolitan Police chief Lord Bernard Hogan-Howe to review the structure of the 43 police forces in England and Wales, with reports indicating the blueprint recommends reducing them to nine regional mega-forces.
The dispute over the future of the City of London Police stems from a broader government review launched following the Police Reform White Paper earlier this year. As reported by Aaron Newbury and Kumail Jaffer of MyLondon, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood ordered Lord Bernard Hogan-Howe in March 2026 to draw up a structural blueprint to replace the 43 existing territorial police forces across England and Wales with fewer, larger regional entities.
Although Lord Hogan-Howe’s formal report has not yet been published, the Financial Times reported that his recommendations will call for the creation of nine new mega-forces—including the absorption of the City of London Police into the Metropolitan Police.
Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley has campaigned heavily in favour of radical consolidation. As reported by Vikram Dodd of The Guardian and Kumail Jaffer of MyLondon, Sir Mark warned in a November 2026 speech that the existing 43-force model is “creaking” and overly bureaucratic, calling the choice one between “the third greatest revolution in British policing or the inevitable decline and fewer bobbies on the beat”. Specifically regarding the City of London Police, which serves as the national policing lead for economic crime, the Metropolitan Police pointed to remarks in which Sir Mark criticised the “fragmented” leadership of the national fight against fraud and cybercrime, which is currently divided between the City force and the National Crime Agency.
How Have Other Regional Mayors and Ministers Responded to the Restructuring Plans?
Thirteen regional mayors signed a joint letter demanding that police force boundaries align with devolved mayoral areas rather than sprawling super-forces, leading ministers to reportedly consider scaling back the mergers.
Sadiq Khan’s intervention aligns him with regional leaders across England who contend that sprawling regional forces would erode democratic oversight. As reported by Aaron Newbury, 13 regional mayors signed a letter in May 2026—when Prime Minister Andy Burnham was still serving as Mayor of Greater Manchester, signed on his behalf by his deputy for policing Kate Green—demanding that police force boundaries match existing mayoral strategic authorities.
Other regional leaders have voiced similar objections. As reported by Josh Halliday and Vikram Dodd of The Guardian, Liverpool City Region Mayor Steve Rotheram described the super-force proposals as “the wolf of centralisation dressed up in sheep’s clothing”, whilst Greater Manchester Mayor Bev Craig and North East Mayor Kim McGuinness warned against dismantling locally accountable policing structures.
According to Aaron Newbury, the Prime Minister is understood to remain sympathetic to the mayors’ concerns regarding devolution and local governance. Consequently, Home Office ministers are reportedly considering watering down the wide-ranging merger proposals—potentially focusing instead on establishing a dedicated national policing service for counter-terrorism and serious organised crime whilst merging only a small number of struggling forces.
Background of the City of London Police and UK Police Force Restructuring
Established in 1839 under the City of London Police Act—a decade after Sir Robert Peel founded the Metropolitan Police—the City of London Police is the smallest territorial police force in the United Kingdom by geographic area, responsible for policing the 1.12-square-mile financial district known as the Square Mile. Despite its compact jurisdiction, the force holds national responsibility as the UK’s National Policing Lead for Fraud and Economic Crime, operating Action Fraud and the National Fraud Intelligence Bureau, and receives substantial direct funding from the City of London Corporation alongside Home Office grants.
Debates over consolidating the 43 territorial police forces of England and Wales have recurred for decades. Previous attempts at compulsory regional mergers—most notably under Home Secretary Charles Clarke in 2005–2006—were abandoned following fierce opposition from local police authorities, chief constables, and MPs over governance, council tax precepts, and loss of local accountability. Subsequent reforms introduced directly elected Police and Crime Commissioners in 2012 and transferred policing oversight to metro mayors in regions such as London and Greater Manchester, deepening the tension between operational centralisation and regional devolution.
How Could This Dispute Affect Londoners, the Financial Sector, and UK Policing Policy?
The outcome of the disagreement between Mayor Sadiq Khan, Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley, and Home Office ministers carries direct implications for policing governance, financial crime enforcement, and national devolution:
- City of London Workers, Residents, and Financial Institutions: Preserving the City of London Police as an independent force would maintain dedicated, high-visibility neighbourhood policing tailored to the Square Mile’s dense commuter population and global financial institutions, backed by City of London Corporation funding rather than competing for resources within the Metropolitan Police’s wider London budget.
- National Fraud and Economic Crime Enforcement: Whether ministers retain the City of London Police’s national economic crime remit or consolidate fraud and cybercrime capabilities into a national service or the Met will directly shape how complex financial investigations are coordinated across the UK.
- English Devolution and Regional Mayors: If the government scales back Lord Bernard Hogan-Howe’s nine-mega-force blueprint in favour of aligning boundaries with mayoral strategic authorities, regional mayors across England will retain direct democratic oversight over their local police forces rather than ceding control to multi-county regional boards.
